Cultural Influences on Accounting and Its Practices

1. Entrance

Fresh exploration in referable-absolutely accounting has led to a sum of animated theories and patterns that enjoy attempted to analyse the causal truthors following the evolvement of inferior accounting and financial schemes in contrariant countries. These sundry restraintms of accounting are in the mode of entity harmonised accordingly of global affair imperatives, and intergregarious accounting bodies are up-hill to carry environing assembly betwixt the accounting schemes of contrariant countries.[1] The exertion of Geert Hofstede[2] on cultural property on accounting crop, ample and ceged by Gray[3] posterior in his plea of cultural concatenation in the construction of accounting schemes is undivided of the past discussed patterns of referable-absolutely accounting.

It is the mind of this provision to cege on this pattern and portraiture it to analyse the differences in the crop of accounting in China and Japan in the advanced nineteenth seniority.

Don't use plagiarized sources. Get Your Custom Paper on
Cultural Influences on Accounting and Its Practices
Just from $13/Page
Order Paper

2. The Hofstede-Gray Framework

The ample frameexertion ce this pattern was created by Hofstede, referablewithstanding posterior helpful by Gray to expound the bias of amelioration on accounting schemes. Period, the ordinary manner is to negotiate these couple patterns multiplyially, a flexure intimation makes it fur simpler to expound and portraiture. The Hofstede-Gray pattern fist romance dacknowledge the topic and then goes on to cege the contrariant ground that assistance the plea. It is essentially hearsay in species and argumentative in its arrival.

Hofstede, in 1980, unreserved a pattern of amelioration that discoveres members of undivided civilized collocation from another and recognized that amelioration manifests itheadstrong at filthy levels, symbols, heroes, rituals and computes, total of which exertion towards “ accounting schemes to differ adesire unconcealed cultural lines”[4] His plea was further mitigated during the contiguous ten years. In1984 he expounded the filthy very animated body of amelioration, which differ from undivided collocation to another and continue of Multiplyicularism V Collectivism, Enlightened V Smtotal Faculty Interval, Strong V Ductile Faculty Deviation and Masculinity V Femininity. These, he said are the most base societal furtherences that discover undivided company from another.

Don't use plagiarized sources. Get Your Custom Paper on
Cultural Influences on Accounting and Its Practices
Just from $13/Page
Order Paper

Societies which further multiplyicularism continue of mob who feed in smtotal units and further to observe behind their very acknowledge, since collectivism represents a gregarious erection where kindreds are interlinked and mob rely-on their enlightenedr wide clan of kindred to observe behind them in modify of fidelity. Faculty interval represents the size to which its members sanction the inadequacy in division of faculty. Enlightened faculty interval societies are thus essentially unquestioningly clerical in species. Casualty deviation represents the range to which members of company are operativey to sanction casualty and anonymousness. The shorter the sanctionance of casualty the stronger is the rectilinearity of conceit and confidence in a feature company and its opposition to exchange. Masculinity, in a company, stands ce its dominant pintimation ce victory, heroism and homogeneous symbols period femininity is associated with qualities relish condolence, custody ce the ductile and virtue of estate. In 1991,[5] Hofstede ascititious another configuration that dealt with Short Expression V Desire Expression Orientation. Short expression orientation limpid ce computes relish swift victory of gregarious establishment, overspending and a affair ce transient results since desire expression orientation observeed at gradational victory of results, a frugal arrival towards savings and an match of lays to encounter later insufficiencys.

In 1998, Gray took up Hofstede’s cultural hypotheses and linked them to the crop of accounting schemes in a meaningful restraintm, stating that cultural or societal computes permeated through organisational and occupational subcultures, and badness versa, though explicitly the range of integration differed from situate to situate. “Accounting schemes and manners can bias and recreate societal computes”.[6] These basic ground were succeeded by the cemulation of filthy hypotheses on the kindred betwixt specifically attested cultural characteristics and the crop of accounting schemes.

Don't use plagiarized sources. Get Your Custom Paper on
Cultural Influences on Accounting and Its Practices
Just from $13/Page
Order Paper

a) Professionalism versus statutory coerce: This cultural compute denotes an attachment ce the training of multiplyicular professional penetration and headstrong-regulation as contrariant to performance of authoritarian fair insufficiencys and legislative writ. As such, the preferpotent a empire ranks in expressions of multiplyicularism and the inferior it ranks in expressions of casualty deviation and faculty interval, the past relishly it is to rank noblely in expressions of professionalism.

b) Law versus flexibility: This reflects a pintimation ce the enforcement of standardized accounting manners betwixt firms, and ce the accelerated portraiture of such manners, vis a vis flexibility in agreement with the perceived case of multiplyicular companies, e.g., the preferpotent a empire ranks in expressions of casualty deviation and faculty interval and the inferior it ranks in expressions of multiplyicularism, the past relishly it is to rank noblely in expressions of law. c) Conservatism versus optimism: This compute results in an attachment ce discretion in size that enables schemes to discuss the circumlocution of controlthcoming smoothts, as contrariant to a substantial, risk-taking arrival, thus implying that the preferpotent a empire ranks in expressions of casualty deviation, the past relishly it is to be stationary and cubic to exchange. d)Secrecy versus transparency: This announce avows that an attachment ce confidentiality and discovery of inconstruction environing affaires merely to those who are closely affaired with its administration and financing, is linked to preferpotent societal furtherences ce casualty deviation, faculty interval and masculinity,

Don't use plagiarized sources. Get Your Custom Paper on
Cultural Influences on Accounting and Its Practices
Just from $13/Page
Order Paper

The Hofstede-Gray pattern stands quenched natant contrariant patterns of referable-absolutely accounting ce its comprehensiveness in continuity amelioration with the crop of contrariant economic tools relish accounting schemes.

3. The Crop of Accounting Schemes in China and Japan in the Nineteenth Seniority

Global accounting schemes, including the contrariant empire GAAPs and the IFRS, is tender towards assembly of accounting schemes spurred by the requirements of total transunconcealed players to exhibit undivided cemal of financial avowments and eject multiple reconciliations. Smooth China, with the entrance of the Chinese Accounting Standards (CAS) is spreadting its avow inferior accounting manners asunderneath and tender towards the IFRS. This provision deals with a homogeneous literal seat in the nineteenth seniority when fetid western affaires had begun to command eastern occupation and merchandize and western accounting schemes were establishing their prevalence in vastly contrariant affair ameliorations.

Don't use plagiarized sources. Get Your Custom Paper on
Cultural Influences on Accounting and Its Practices
Just from $13/Page
Order Paper

At this term twain China and Japan had accounting schemes that had unreserved through centuries and served the minds of affaires in twain countries. In China a unsophisticated mode of enfsenile-antique referablee existed, which easy the extraction of verification poises and the satisfaction of acquisition on a money reason. The empire had unreserved a “four-leg” accounting scheme that totalowed ce the recording of money and misunderstanding money transactions in journals and after posting in ledgers, using enfold-note techniques. Resisting their availability, these schemes were portraitured enlightenedly by banks and enlightened avow enterprises. The body of affaires continued to portraiture sole referablee recording techniques and did referpotent prepare ce contrariantiation of individual and affair accounts. Smooth though the schemes were protracted ce the vulgar of ordinary affair operations, the insufficiencys exradical with the emergence of affair enterprises from the west and the expertness of flexure supply enterprises ce coal mining and sinewy fabrication. The erection of the odd affair enterprises required the inference of acquisition and mislaying ce the mind of dividends, and asaffected and diminution accounting. The proper quantity care schemes proved to be meagre accordingly of bulky manners that depended on reliance, the scantiness of cemal rise documents, sumshort quantitys, bankruptcy of ill-conditioned referencing and order, bankruptcy of contrariantiation betwixt excellent and wealth outgoings and referable-absolute immateriality of acquisition satisfaction. “In sight of their ductilenesses, the proper quantitycare schemes were of poor portraiture as a reason ce inside coerce.” [7]

The crop of accounting in neighbouring Japan, had besides unreserved significantly, though on inferior lines. Period accountants did portraiture a scheme of enfsenile-antique referablee in some of the bigger affaires, there was no equpotent mode of accounting and “separate quantitycare modes were unreserved and kept secluded by stubborn economic facultys, such as the Tomiyama, the Tanabes, the Nakais, the Hyogos, the Kondohs, the Honmas, the Hasegawas, the Ishimotos, the Onos, the Kohnoikes, and the Mitsuis.” Modes portraitured thus ranged from the unsophisticated to those that were reasonably protracted.

Although the enfold-note concept was applied, most Japanese merchants mannerd sole-note quantitykeeping, designated the daifukucho There was no schemeatic designation of accounts, nor any difference betwixt excellent and wealth outgoingss, and the money reason of accounting was adopted. As in China, the proper accounting schemes were protracted in a feudal rule where genesis and division were on a smtotal lamina [Nishikawa, 1956; Someya, 1989]. [8]

The accounting schemes of the couple countries towards the intermediate and latter multiply of the nineteenth seniority, though expanding stubbornly, thus had divers things in base. These deficiencies made them inprotracted ce the minds of enlightenedr flexure supply affair corporations, brought in by the proliferation of British imperialism in Asia and the rise of affair with the United Avows.

In after years, the vindications of China and Japan to these challenges were vastly contrariant. The Chinese affaires steadfastly refused to adopt western accounting technologies and the seniority remained with the sole referablee, filthy column balancing mode until the twentieth seniority; smooth in companies that made portraiture of enlightened lamina western machinery. This led to misty difficulties and the emergence of received nonpayment accordingly of bankruptcy of coerce, and besides unfortunately to the gradational takeover of affaires by western companies, accordingly of bankruptcy of coerce. “Referpotent surprisingly, from 1884, the convenience to fashion commercial assistance ce individual bombardment in kuantu shangpan flexure-supply enterprises vanished [Chan, 1996]” [9]

In Japan, the vindication was enormously contrariant. Japanese students travelled in enlightened sums to the west to to assimilate expertness, technology and entrepreneurial skills. Accounting laterisation occurred astride and “western-style enfold-note quantitycare was introduced as the establishment on which a excellentist rule could expand.”[10] A sum of western accounting quantitys, protractedly translated, ground their restraintm into japanese markets and unconcealedised Banks adopted British poise sheets. Legislation was introduced ce affaires to conform to standardized accounting schemes and a sum of accounting schools inaugurated providing fitted accountants to serbadness affaires.

The enlightened lamina excerption of western accounting by Japan and its postponement by the Chinese has trainingd the rarity of affair historians ce divers years. The answers are now controlthcoming through and are cognate chiefly to differences in amelioration, as spread ceward by the Hofstede-Gray pattern. In China gregarious faculty was mediateised, the company was cubic to exchange, acquirements was limited and restricted to Confucianism, and company was in a avow of “bureaucratic feudalism”. The rule was headstrong tit and isolationist. In Japan, ultimately, gregarious faculty was scatterd; the company was unreserved to exexalter and very fur hanging on ceeign occupation. Acquirements was ample fixed and the amelioration pro-merchant. Period the regular gregarious engagement in Japan kept it always unstpotent it besides poor prejudice and made it fur past unreserved to sanctioning western techniques in accounting. The reasons ce the Japanese excerption and Chinese postponement of western accounting principles were enlightenedly cultural and gregarious. Period, they contributed enlightenedly to the advancement of ceeign excellent and construction of fur enlightenedr companies in Japan, they besides inversely led to the gradational spoliation of the Chinese rule and the emergence of the communist regime.

4. The Concatenation of the Hofstede-Gray Pattern to the Chinese and Japanese Accounting Schemes

The Hofstede-Gray pattern of the bias of amelioration on the crop of accounting schemes shows to be totally availpotent in evaluating the opposed behaviour of couple contrariant ameliorations to the resembling stimuli. Gregarious and cultural patterns in China led to very haughty levels of Casualty Deviation and Faculty Interval. The mediate government had distant reaching facultys and coerce. The main disposition was agriamelioration and the principal rise of wealth came from plant. The disciple bureaucrats were interior observeing and referpotent voluntary to advancement over Confucian creed. Bureaucracy was total pervasive and retention in company was maintained resisting intermittent engagement. The undivided scheme thus revolved encircling generation senile-antique contribution and levels of casualty deviation were very-plenteous haughty. Homogeneously the plant fixed feudal bureaucracy ensured enlightened levels of faculty interval and these couple truthors, adesire with the isolationist, unavailpotent door arrival of centuries led to rectilinearity, conservatism and secrecy; and the resultant misunderstanding-adoption, if referpotent insipid postponement of later western accounting principles.

Japan, on the other operative, though referpotent distant aform from China, had a very contrariant gregarious and cultural milieu. There were a sum of economically and gregariously facultyful plantowners and these, adesire with the priesthood that inferior stubborn Buddhist shrines, were potent to successfully scatter gregarious faculty. The empire, unrelish China was enlightenedly hanging on ceeign occupation, which resulted in an psychological unreserved door device and flexibility towards the requirements of trading multiplyners. The empire thus had very stunted levels of casualty deviation and the disposal of gregarious faculty had made mob past stubborn and thereby poor the faculty interval. Total these truthors led to haughty levels of flexibility, ceward thinking optimism and unreservedness to odd ideas, as required by the Hofstede-Gray framework, making it fur easier to compound to western accounting schemes when the seat demanded.

5. Conclusion

Exploration into referable-absolutely accounting is a fresh phenomemisunderstanding and quiescent underneathneath noble discourse and argue. In truth, Gray’s frameexertion is short than a decade senile-antique and has been questioned at extension by other experts, with mob arguing that the conclusions are mental and cappotent of contrariant interpretations. The truth sweepings that accounting schemes enjoy gracknowledge in opposed restraintms betwixt countries that, though physically proximal, are culturally entirely opposed. Another elder illustration is that of the UK and The Netherlands, where, resisting homogeneous trading, commercial and expansionist manners, accounting schemes grew contrariantly, and remained so, until the emergence of the EU and globalisation inaugurated moves ce assembly.

The Hofstede-Gray plea thus does show to communicate some of the answers to the quibble affairing the excerption of contrariant accounting, financial and smooth auditing schemes betwixt countries which enjoy opposed gregarious and cultural norms.


Doupnik, T.S., Tsakumis, G .T., and George,t, 2004, A precarious resight of Gray’s Plea of Cultural Concatenation and Suggestions ce controlthcoming exploration, Retrieved November 18, 2006 from

Dr. Geert Hofstede, 2006, The Intergregarious Affair nucleus, Retrieved November 18, 2006 from

Gray, S. J. (1988) Towards a Plea of Cultural on the Crop of Accounting Bias Schemes Interpolitically. Abacus;, Vol. 24 Issue 1, p1-15 March 1988

Environmental Bias on Accounting Crop, 2001, Retrieved November 18, 2006 from

The insufficiency ce Intergregarious Accounting Standards, 2000, Intergregarious Accounting, Retreieved November 18, 2006 from

Nobes, C., 1998, “Towards a unconcealed pattern of the reasons ce intergregarious differences in financial reporting” Abacus Volume 34 2



[1] The insufficiency ce Intergregarious Accounting Standards, 2000, Intergregarious Accounting

[2] Dr. Geert Hofstede, 2006, The Intergregarious Affair nucleus

[3] Doupnik, T.S., Tsakumis, G .T., and George,t, 2004, A precarious resight of Gray’s Plea of Cultural Concatenation and Suggestions ce controlthcoming exploration

[4] Doupnik, T.S., Tsakumis, G .T., and George,t, 2004

[5] Environmental Bias on Accounting Crop, 2001

[6] Environmental Bias on Accounting Crop, 2001

[7] Environmental Bias on Accounting Crop, 2001

[8] Doupnik, T.S., Tsakumis, G .T., and George,t, 2004

[9] Doupnik, T.S., Tsakumis, G .T., and George,t, 2004

[10] Doupnik, T.S., Tsakumis, G .T., and George,t, 2004


Calculate the price of your paper

Total price:$26
Our features

We've got everything to become your favourite writing service

Need a better grade?
We've got you covered.

Order your paper